(Oh, whoa) all this time we've been together (Oh) and I still don't know how you feel Sometimes I wish you'd just (whoa) Talk to me Maybe it's make-believe, maybe it can be true? I try to tell myself I'm not in love with you I thought that I knew everything ('thing) I guess I don't know anything, yeah I get emotional (yeah) and hypothetical Wondering if there are all kinds of things I'm not supposed to know I try my best to let it go (let it go) Baby, then you bring me back, bring me back You lift my feet off of the ground Keep me spinnin' around and around I don't ever wanna come down from your arms You tell me that you need me, then you walk away Keep promisin' forever with the words you say, "It's true" (true, true) Don't know what I'm supposed to do I'm stuck in the middle with you, you, you, with you, you Oh, boy, you got me really confused Don't know what I'm supposed to do? I'm stuck in the middle with you You were the spark, light in the dark Gave you my everything (ha) Pullin' me in, pushing me out Pullin' me back again (ha) Don't know if your mind is made up But I know that nobody wanna be stuck (ha) You are the one that I want All I can promise you now is my love You say you want me (want me), you say you care (care) When we're together (together), are you even there? And you gave me the keys to your heart Yeah, you made me believe from the start Now all that I know is I got all this love, I won't take back My love, my love, my love, my love You lift my feet off of the ground Keep me spinnin' around and around I don't ever wanna come down from your arms You tell me that you need me, then you walk away Keep promisin' forever with the words you say, "It's true" (true, true) Don't know what I'm supposed to do? I'm stuck in the middle with you, you, you, with you, you Oh, boy, you got me really confused Don't know what I'm supposed to do? I'm stuck in the middle with you I've tried, and I've tried to be good to myself, good for my health Is it selfish if I'm constantly turning to you? (To you) If you knew what I'm feeling right now You'd comfort my heart You tell me that you need me, then you walk away (you tell me, yeah) Keep promisin' forever with the words you say, "It's true" (true, true) Don't know what I'm supposed to do? (Oh) I'm stuck in the middle with you, you, you (with you), with you, you (you) Oh, boy, you got me really confused Don't know what I'm supposed to do? I'm stuck in the middle with you